Are you wondering how shifts in the energy sector and commodity markets might impact your retirement income? In this episode of The Financial Hour of The Tom Dupree Show, Tom Dupree, Mike Johnson, James Dupree, and Clark Dupree reveal why oil company stocks are rising even as oil prices fall—and what this means for Kentucky retirement planning.
For investors approaching or enjoying retirement, understanding how quality energy companies provide both income and stability becomes crucial. This conversation demonstrates why personalized investment management focused on individual stock ownership often outperforms mass-market approaches during commodity market volatility.
The Energy Sector Paradox: Lower Oil Prices, Higher Stock Values
One of 2025’s most surprising market developments has been the disconnect between oil prices and energy company performance. Oil prices dropped 19% this year, yet the energy sector gained approximately 3%.
“This is the first time this century that that has happened,” explains Mike Johnson. “Typically the market prices those producers to track the underlying commodity.”
This divergence reflects important factors that Kentucky retirement investors should understand:
Policy Changes Create Investment Opportunities
Recent regulatory shifts have created a more favorable environment for energy companies. Occidental Petroleum quantified benefits from recent legislation at $700-800 million for 2025-2026 alone. Combined with emission standard rollbacks, these changes have extended market expectations for fossil fuel demand.
Integrated Oil Companies Provide Natural Hedging
Major companies like Chevron and Exxon operate with advantages that pure drilling companies lack. They have multiple profit centers including exploration, production, and refining.
“With oil prices in the upper fifties, that means for the refining business their input costs go down,” Johnson notes. “So that’s a more profitable line of business. It’s like a natural built-in hedge.”
This structural advantage makes integrated oil companies attractive for investors seeking stable dividend income rather than commodity speculation.
Lessons from 2014: Why Energy Companies Are Stronger Today
The energy sector’s transformation since 2014 offers crucial insights. When oil peaked at $150 per barrel in 2014, companies embarked on aggressive drilling. By 2020, oil prices had essentially dropped to zero.
“Through blood, sweat, and tears, they were forced to become more efficient,” Tom Dupree observes about the industry’s evolution.
Today’s energy companies focus on high-quality drilling opportunities with strong returns rather than volume at any cost. This disciplined approach creates sustainable businesses capable of maintaining dividends during commodity downturns.
Quality Companies Over Commodity Speculation
“This is why we invest in companies that actually make a profit,” Dupree emphasizes. “What we’re trying to do is invest in things that make a profit and pay a dividend and do something that’s valuable.”
Silver, Gold, and Bitcoin: Understanding Commodity Risk for Retirees
Precious metals have experienced significant volatility. Silver mining company Coeur Mining traded at $8 in August, surged to $24, then pulled back to $19—all while silver and gold continued broader upward trends.
Why Commodities Don’t Fit Retirement Income Strategies
Mike Johnson explains why Dupree Financial Group approaches commodities cautiously in retirement portfolios:
“Gold has no earnings. There’s no dividend associated with it. In a bear market on the commodity, the gold mining companies are gonna stop paying the dividend. In the context of retirement investing and producing an income, it’s just a speculative commodity.”
While commodities can appreciate—gold and silver performed exceptionally well recently due to dollar concerns—their lack of earnings and dividends makes them problematic as core holdings for income-focused investors.
The Free Cash Flow Advantage
Chevron’s 6.8% free cash flow yield versus the S&P 500’s 3.4% illustrates why Dupree Financial Group focuses on individual company ownership. Free cash flow represents actual cash available to shareholders after expenses, providing more accurate valuation than simple price-to-earnings ratios.
Companies with strong free cash flow sustain and grow dividends even during commodity weakness, providing the income stability retirees depend upon.
What Kentucky Retirement Investors Really Need
Clark Dupree, working with prospective clients, offers insight into what drives people to seek professional investment management:
“They’re looking for a relationship. They’re looking for somebody to give them peace of mind.”
This highlights the distinction between Dupree Financial Group’s personalized approach and commoditized experiences at large national firms.
Transparency Over Complexity
Many firms use complex jargon that creates client dependency rather than understanding. As Clark notes:
“Sometimes advisors rely on codependent relationships that are not healthy. When you talk over somebody’s head, a client may feel disempowered without you.”
The team emphasizes clear communication about portfolio holdings, investment rationale, and risk management. Every client owns investments in a separately managed account rather than pooled mutual funds.
“We don’t own the stocks that we own and the bonds we own on our balance sheet,” Johnson clarifies. “We hold them on behalf of our clients. That’s the difference.”
Specialized Retirement Income Expertise
Unlike generalist advisors serving all investor types, Dupree Financial Group specializes in retirement investing and income generation for clients ages 50 and above.
“Our specialty is retirement investing and producing that income stream for clients,” Johnson explains. “To concentrate on an income stream and mitigate risk. The byproduct of that is what the returns are.”
Every investment decision centers on generating reliable income and managing downside risk. Total returns relative to the S&P 500 become secondary to these primary objectives.
Key Takeaways for Kentucky Retirement Investors
- Energy companies can provide attractive income even when commodity prices decline, especially integrated oil companies with multiple profit centers
- The 2014-2020 oil collapse taught energy companies efficiency lessons that make today’s dividend-paying energy stocks more sustainable
- Commodities like gold, silver, and Bitcoin lack earnings and dividend characteristics necessary for reliable retirement income
- Free cash flow yield provides better insight into dividend sustainability than price-to-earnings ratios
- Separately managed accounts offer transparency that pooled investments cannot match
- Specialized retirement investment management serves pre-retirees and retirees better than generalist approaches
- Clear communication creates empowered investors rather than dependent relationships
Notable Quotes from This Episode
On energy transformation: “Through blood, sweat, and tears, they were forced to become more efficient. Everything from… the reason for that was in 2014, oil hit $150 a barrel, and by 2020, it had basically dropped to zero.” – Tom Dupree
On commodity risks: “Gold has no earnings. There’s no dividend associated with it. In a bear market on the commodity, the gold mining companies are gonna stop paying the dividend.” – Mike Johnson
On investment philosophy: “This is why we invest in companies that actually make a profit. We may not keep up with gold or silver that really moves up in a hurry, but over time we think we’ll outperform them.” – Tom Dupree
On client relationships: “They’re looking for a relationship. They’re looking for somebody to give them peace of mind.” – Clark Dupree
Frequently Asked Questions About Energy Investing and Retirement Portfolios
Q: Why are energy stocks performing well even though oil prices have dropped?
A: Energy company stocks reflect multiple factors beyond current commodity prices including regulatory changes, improved efficiency since 2014-2020, attractive dividend yields, and recognition that fossil fuels will remain necessary longer than expected. Integrated oil companies particularly benefit because lower oil prices reduce refining input costs.
Q: Should retirees invest in gold and silver?
A: While precious metals can appreciate significantly, they generate no earnings or dividends. During bear markets lasting a decade or more, they provide no income while potentially declining. For Kentucky retirement portfolios focused on reliable income, dividend-paying quality companies typically serve investors better.
Q: What makes integrated oil companies better investments than pure drilling companies?
A: Integrated companies like Chevron and Exxon own both drilling operations and refining facilities, creating natural hedges. When oil prices are low, refining divisions benefit from lower input costs. Pure drilling companies lack this balance and remain entirely exposed to commodity swings, making dividends less sustainable.
Q: How does personalized investment management differ from large national firms?
A: Large firms typically assign clients to counselors who recommend pre-packaged mutual fund portfolios. Personalized management provides direct access to portfolio managers who build custom portfolios of individual stocks and bonds in separately managed accounts, providing complete transparency about holdings and fees.
Q: What is free cash flow yield and why does it matter?
A: Free cash flow yield measures actual cash a company generates after expenses relative to stock price. Unlike earnings with non-cash items, free cash flow represents real cash available for dividends. Companies with high free cash flow yields (Chevron’s 6.8% versus the S&P 500’s 3.4%) have greater capacity to sustain dividends during challenges.
Q: Why specialize in retirement investing rather than serving all investors?
A: Retirement investing requires different strategies than accumulation. Retirees need reliable income, downside protection, and portfolios sustaining withdrawals for 30+ years. Specializing in clients ages 50 and above allows deep expertise in income-focused strategies and risk management techniques, serving this phase most effectively.
Take Control of Your Kentucky Retirement Portfolio
If you’re approaching retirement or already retired and want a local financial advisor providing direct access to portfolio managers rather than assigned counselors, Dupree Financial Group offers a different approach.
Our three-generation, Kentucky-based team specializes in creating personalized, income-focused portfolios using individual stock and bond ownership rather than mass-market mutual funds. You deserve transparency about what you own, why you own it, and exactly what fees you’re paying.
Schedule Your Complimentary Portfolio Review
Discover how personalized investment management focused on dividend income and risk mitigation can provide greater peace of mind for your retirement years. Call Dupree Financial Group at (859) 233-0400 or visit dupreefinancial.com to schedule your complimentary portfolio analysis.
Our team will review your current holdings, discuss your income needs and risk tolerance, and explain how our approach differs from large national firms. There’s no obligation—just straightforward guidance from Kentucky investment professionals who put your retirement security first.
Explore More Resources: